Who should I have as my fantasy baseball Utility man?

i'd play loney and rasmus, maybe even drew over headley. loney is a good hitter, good for rbi's, and can even steal you a base. drew is streaky, but he has some power, and a lot of opportunites for runs and rbi's in that boston lineup....the same goes for rasmus. i don't trust anybody in the padre lineup, other than a-gone. problem is, is that all these players are slumping, which is weird, but the best hitters will come out of it first...loney is it out of this bunch....drew/rasmus over headley.